Before You Say Yes
Is God calling you to lead a pilgrimage? How priests discern, from false prudence to the gift of counsel, so your parish returns changed, not just traveled.
The question rarely arrives as a thunderclap. It comes sideways. A parishioner catches you after the 10:30 Mass and says she has wanted to see Lourdes her whole life and would go tomorrow if you led it. A brother priest comes home from the Holy Land and cannot stop talking about offering Mass in the Grotto of the Nativity. Or a quiet pull you cannot explain keeps surfacing in your Holy Hour. If you are discerning whether to lead a pilgrimage, take that small persistence seriously. It may be a call rather than a passing idea.
Advent is a few weeks off, and with it a new liturgical year, the season when pastors settle their commitments for the year ahead. It is a fitting time to ask the question properly, with the tools the Church gives us for every other vocational question, rather than letting the calendar decide by default.
A Call, Not a Good Idea
Fr. Clinton Sensat, a priest who has led pilgrimages for years and the author of By A Different Way: A Catholic Guide to Pilgrim Spirituality, makes a claim that sounds strange at first hearing: there is such a thing as a vocation to pilgrimage. God calls people to it. His evidence is the Magi. They did not follow a star out of restlessness or curiosity about Judea. They were summoned by the One who made the star. He quotes St. Peter Chrysologus: “When would a Magus have sought God save by God’s command?”
The pattern runs the length of Scripture. Abraham’s life pivots on an order to leave: “Go forth from your land, your relatives, and from your father’s house to a land that I will show you” (Genesis 12:1). Elijah is fed by an angel and told, “Get up and eat or the journey will be too much for you!” before he walks forty days to Horeb (1 Kings 19:7). None of these people decided to travel. They were sent.
For a priest the call doubles. You are being asked whether to go as a pilgrim and whether to go as a shepherd, and those are different questions. Some priests are called to the first and not yet to the second. A priest called to lead a pilgrimage carries his people’s intentions inside his own, forms their hearts before departure, offers Mass at the holy places for them, and then helps them keep what they received once they are home. It is a pastoral assignment and deserves the same care as any other.
Discerning Whether to Lead a Pilgrimage: Four Ways the Decision Gets Made
Fr. Sensat borrows a framework from St. Thomas Aquinas and applies it to this exact decision. Most of us slide into one of these four modes without noticing which.
False prudence. St. Thomas calls it prudence of the flesh, and he is blunt that it is a vice rather than a virtue (Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 47, a. 13; q. 55). It looks like wisdom. It is rationalization wearing a cassock. In pilgrimage discernment it supplies a steady stream of reasons not to go: travel is unpleasant, the cost looks extravagant, the parish cannot spare you, the thought of leading forty people through a foreign country is more vulnerability than you signed up for. Fr. Sensat’s warning is uncomfortable: “We follow our impulses, and then justify them as the will of God.” One test: did the reason arrive before the reluctance, or after it?
Natural prudence. This is the real virtue, the one the Catechism describes as disposing “practical reason to discern our true good in every circumstance and to choose the right means of achieving it” (CCC 1806). Can you manage it? Is there a window in the parish year? Will your knees hold up? Who covers the funerals and the weekend Masses? They deserve honest answers, but they are not the last word. Fr. Sensat’s distinction: natural prudence can tell you that you need a vacation. Only supernatural prudence can tell you that you need a pilgrimage.
Supernatural prudence. Reasoning from faith and revelation as well as common sense. Applied to a parish, the question becomes: is there a grace your people need that the ordinary rhythms of parish life are not reaching? A parish that has gone cold, or a generation of families who have never seen the universal Church with their own eyes. If faith sees a good like that and reason sees a way to it, Fr. Sensat sets the bar: “As long as a decision was made rationally, clearly, and with faith, that is all that is required.” You do not need a sign in the sky.
Counsel. The fourth way is a gift of the Holy Spirit. St. Thomas explains that in counsel “the Holy Ghost is said to move the rational creature,” and that prudence “is chiefly perfected and helped through being ruled and moved by the Holy Ghost” (II-II, q. 52). Fr. Sensat’s image is a boat: the virtues are paddles we can pick up any time, the gifts are sails that catch a wind we do not control. When counsel moves, the conflicting thoughts fall away and you know. Two cautions. The gift is not a prerequisite; God “wants them to be reasonable,” Fr. Sensat writes, and a sound decision need not wait for certainty. And counsel usually comes through other people, which is St. Thomas’s own point: the gift takes the posture of one who seeks advice from someone wiser. Your spiritual director, a priest who has led a group and will tell you what he would do differently, your bishop if the absence will be long.
The Objections Worth Taking Seriously
Not every hesitation is false prudence. Some deserve a real answer, and Fr. Sensat is a credible witness, having held most of them himself for years. The pilgrimages he observed looked like “posh vacations.” The cost seemed to violate simplicity of life. And the deepest objection, the one most priests will recognize: God is everywhere. “Wasn’t every chalice at every Mass equal to the Holy Grail?”
He came to answer each. Sacrifice is different from prodigality; money saved for a holy purpose already shares in it. A pilgrimage that is hard, prayerful, and lived “beneath the shadow of the Cross” is no vacation with Mass attached. And yes, God is everywhere, but Scripture does not treat every place as equal. Jacob woke at Bethel and said, “How awesome this place is!” (Genesis 28:17). The Word took flesh in one particular town. Some places are holy, and bringing people to them is a pastoral act rather than an indulgence.
What finally changed his mind was experience, not argument: a week at Ars and Paray-le-Monial before ordination that left him “radically changed,” and then, as a priest, leading a Fatima pilgrimage whose fruits in his people were still visible years later. His conclusion: “Pilgrimage was not merely a nice experience for me, but a pastoral tool of enduring power for my people.” A priest weighing this should at least ask whether his objections are theological, or whether they are simply unfamiliarity.
Questions to Pray Through Before You Decide
Discernment needs content. These are the questions Fr. Sensat suggests for anyone discerning a call to lead a pilgrimage, adapted for a pastor.
Why this, and why now? Pilgrimage has three classic purposes: veneration, petition, and thanksgiving. Which is your parish’s? A parish still grieving a closed school may need to carry a petition. A parish marking a jubilee may owe God thanks. St. Benedict kept his sharpest words for the gyrovagues, monks “always on the move, with no stability,” who “indulge their own wills” (Rule, ch. 1). A pilgrimage with no purpose is a gyrovague’s outing with better scenery. Name the purpose before you name the destination. Fr. Sensat keeps the question open: “Sometimes God doesn’t call us to something but rather towards something.” The answer may be “not this year,” or “yes, but Assisi before Jerusalem,” or “go yourself first, then bring them.”
Who would come, and what do they need? Picture actual faces. The widow who told you she has nothing left to look forward to. The couples whose marriages are tired but not broken. Fr. Sensat’s instruction to planners is the whole job in one sentence: “It’s not enough to lead pilgrims to a place. We should also lead them into God.” If you can see yourself doing that for these particular people, the call is getting clearer, and the fruit a group pilgrimage leaves in a parish tends to outlast the photographs.
Can you go as a pilgrim yourself? A leader who goes as a manager comes home as a manager. The priest who leads well also kneels, fasts, offers up the delayed bus and the five o’clock departure, and lets the places work on him in front of his people. Fr. Sensat confesses to pilgrimages where he was “a camel,” eyes dull, carrying souvenirs on his back, “returning home just as smelly and unconverted as I left.” Ask whether you are willing to be changed where your parishioners can see it.
Am I deciding from desolation? St. Ignatius’s rule holds: in a time of desolation, make no change (Spiritual Exercises, 318). A priest in the trough of a hard year, tempted either to escape into a pilgrimage or to refuse one out of sheer exhaustion, should wait for consolation before deciding either way. The question will keep. Answer it when you can see.
Returning by a Different Way
SCRIPTURE“And having been warned in a dream not to return to Herod, they departed for their country by another way.”MATTHEW 2:12
St. Gregory the Great read the Magi’s homeward road as the pattern of every Christian life: “Our country is paradise. And when we have known Jesus, we are forbidden to return to it by the way which we came” (Homily 10 on the Gospels). That is the measure of this discernment too. A pilgrimage that leaves a parish exactly as it found it was a pleasant excursion. One that sends forty people home by another road was a work of grace, and someone had to say yes to it first.
If you find, after honest prayer, that the reluctance was false prudence, that the practicalities have answers, and that faith sees a good your people need, then you have discerned enough. You do not have to wait for the wind to fill the sails before you pick up the paddles. Fr. Sensat’s closing words apply to the shepherd before they apply to the flock: “We have chosen to be pilgrims. Now we must resolve to be saints.”
For the interior groundwork of pilgrimage itself, the pilgrim’s posture rather than the tourist’s, the post on preparing for a Catholic pilgrimage the way the Magi did is the place to begin, for you and eventually for the people you may be called to lead.

